WTO Reported As Ruling Against Boeing in Subsidy Case

A few months ago the World Trade Organization (WTO) ruled that EADS (EADS:P) had received illegal subsidies from various European governments in the form of launch aid loans and tax breaks. The decision was quickly seized upon by Boeing (BA) supporters who want the Department of Defense and the U.S. Air Force to take the advantage these subsidies gave EADS into account in their source selection for the KC-X aerial tanker.

At the same time the WTO was considering a complaint by European governments that Boeing’s (BA) many years of contracts from the American government also aided them in developing their products and reducing their costs. The results of that case were leaked today and they indicate that the WTO will provide some criticism of the U.S. support.

This then was quoted by EADS’ American allies to reiterate the need for these not to be considered in the decision of who will win the contract to build over $35 billion of new tankers.

Because the rulings will not be exactly even and cancel each other out the argument will still go on even as the WTO leaves the issue. Unfortunately the decline of the world’s industrial base to where there are only two Western companies able to build this type of aircraft have led to this situation.

There is no easy resolution to the problem and no decision by the U.S.A.F. that will placate everybody. Once again the chance of a protest seems to be a given.

1 Comment »

  1. WTO Report States Boeing Received Illegal Aid Effect on KC-X Undetermined Said,

    January 31, 2011 @ 6:05 pm

    […] the Chicago based company received illegal subsidies from the U.S. Government and four states. In September this finding was also leaked as a preliminary to the completion of the final […]

Leave a Comment